Homemade Potato Gnocchi

Homemade potato gnocchi sounds like one of those recipes you’d only tackle on a free weekend, but once you try making gnocchi from scratch, you realize it’s a lot more approachable than it seems. Over the years, it’s become one of those meals I make when the house is a little louder, everyone is hanging around the kitchen, and someone inevitably wanders over to see what’s happening on the counter.

The process itself has turned into a family thing. My kids are older now, but they always end up joining in when I start rolling the dough. Someone cuts the ropes into little pillows, someone else dusts them with flour, and we all stand around the counter chatting while the tray fills up. There’s something grounding about it, almost like the kitchen slows down for a moment.

What I love most about potato gnocchi is how simple the ingredients are. You don’t need much, and you don’t need a sauce if you don’t want one. Some nights we just toss the gnocchi in olive oil and salt and eat them straight from the pan. Other nights we crisp them a bit longer because everyone picks at them before they ever make it to the plate. It’s the kind of recipe that becomes part of your routine without you even noticing.

What Is Gnocchi?

Gnocchi are small Italian dumplings made mostly from potatoes, a bit of flour, and an egg to bring everything together. They’re not quite pasta and not quite a bread dumpling; they sit somewhere in between, which is why the texture feels so soft when you bite into them.

What I love about gnocchi is that they’re simple at their core. Families in Italy have been rolling them by hand forever, each home with its own little habits and tricks. When I first learned how to make them, I expected some complicated technique, but it really comes down to using the right potatoes and handling the dough gently. That’s it.

Because the flavor is mild, gnocchi work with almost anything. Butter and herbs, creamy sauces, roasted vegetables, shrimp, chicken… they go wherever you want to take them. Once you make them at home, you realize they’re a lot more versatile than you’d expect.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The texture is unbeatable
  Homemade gnocchi has a tenderness you just don’t get from store-bought versions. They stay soft in the center while holding their shape, which makes them perfect for tossing with anything from butter to heavier sauces.
• They adapt to whatever meal you’re planning
  These little dumplings work with bright, fresh dishes or richer, creamier ones. If you’re keeping things light, they’re great next to the BLT Balsamic Chicken Avocado Feta Salad. For a seafood dinner, they sit beautifully alongside Creamy Lemon Parmesan Shrimp. And on nights when you want something balanced, they pair well with One Pan Honey Lemon Chicken Asparagus.
• You can flavor them in endless ways
  Once you learn the base potato gnocchi recipe, you can switch things up anytime. Add herbs to the dough, pan-fry them for extra crisp edges, or toss them with lemon, garlic, or even browned butter for a quick upgrade.
• They freeze well for busy days
  A batch of homemade gnocchi in the freezer makes weeknights easier. They cook straight from frozen in minutes, which is perfect when dinner needs to happen fast without sacrificing quality.

Ingredients for the perfect Gnocchis

Save this recipe!

Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new recipes from us every week!

Email *

Save

• Potatoes
  The type of potato completely changes the texture of your gnocchi. Starchy potatoes (like Russets) break down softly and keep the dough fluffy, which means you don’t have to add much flour. Less flour = lighter gnocchi. When I first started making gnocchi, I tried using waxy potatoes and they turned the dough sticky and heavy. The right potato is the difference between delicate little pillows and chewy dumplings.
• Parmesan
  Parmesan isn’t just for flavor. When you mix a little into the dough, it adds saltiness without extra moisture, which helps the gnocchi keep their shape as they cook. It also adds a gentle nuttiness that makes the dough taste “finished,” even before you add a sauce. It’s one of those quiet ingredients that you only notice when it’s missing.
• Tarragon
  This is the ingredient that always surprises people. Tarragon brings a soft sweetness and a hint of something herbal that lifts the whole dish. It isn’t strong or overpowering, but it gives the gnocchi a personality they wouldn’t have otherwise. I started adding it after using leftovers from another dinner, and it stuck because it adds something special without feeling fancy.
• Cayenne
  A pinch of cayenne wakes up the flavor without turning the gnocchi spicy. It adds warmth, not heat. You won’t consciously taste it, but the whole dish feels more balanced. Especially when serving the gnocchi with creamy sauces, that tiny bit of warmth keeps everything from tasting flat.
• Egg yolk & flour
  The yolk gives structure without making the dough tough. Flour binds everything together, but only just enough to make the dough workable. Too much flour and the gnocchi turn dense; too little and they fall apart in boiling water. These two ingredients are the reason the gnocchi hold their shape and still melt in your mouth.

Note: Find the full list of ingredients and measurements in the Recipe Card.

Tips & Troubleshooting

Watch the dough, not the clock. Gnocchi dough changes depending on the potatoes, the weather, even the humidity in the kitchen. If it feels sticky, give it a light dusting of flour. If it feels stiff, stop kneading; overworking it makes the gnocchi heavy. I show exactly what the dough should look like in my step-by-step video, which helps more than any description ever could.

Cut, lift, and move with the right tools. I used to shape everything with a knife until I switched to a small bench scraper I found on Amazon. It keeps the cuts clean and helps lift the dough without squishing it. If you’re making a big batch, a scraper honestly saves you so much frustration.

Ridges or smooth, use something that works for you. If you’re going for that classic ridged look, a simple gnocchi board makes the process easier, especially when you’re rolling dozens at a time. You can use the back of a fork, but the board keeps the shape neater and faster. Smooth gnocchi are great too, especially if you plan to pan-fry them later.

If they fall apart in the pot… The dough needed a little more flour, or the water was boiling too hard. A gentle simmer is all you need. If the first one disintegrates, fix the dough before cooking the rest. This is normal, so don’t panic.

If they turn dense or chewy, That usually means too much flour or too much kneading. The moment the dough comes together, stop. You’re aiming for soft and barely handled, not smooth like bread dough.

And finally, When in doubt, test one. I always boil a single gnocchi first. If it holds its shape and floats quickly, the dough is perfect. If not, adjust and keep going. This tiny test saves entire batches.

How To Make Gnocchis

It’s soft dough, a little rolling, and some hot water. Just trust your hands and keep flour nearby.

1. Boil the potatoes. Peel, cut, and boil until fork-tender. Not mushy, just soft enough to mash without effort.

2. Mash and season. Drain well, then mash while they’re still warm. Add salt, cayenne, tarragon, and olive oil. The mix should smell like comfort already.

3. Make the dough. Add parmesan, flour, and the egg yolk. Use your hands to bring it all together. Don’t knead, just mix until smooth.

4. Roll and cut. Divide the dough into pieces and roll each into a log. Slice into bite-sized pillows. Light pressure, no stress.

5. Boil until they float. Drop them into salted boiling water. When they float, they’re done. Move to ice water so they stop cooking and stay tender.

6. Pan-fry (if you want to). A little olive oil in a hot pan, a few minutes per side, and they get crispy, golden edges that are impossible to resist.

Homemade gnocchi is one of those dishes that shifts depending on what you put beside it. If you want something creamy without going overboard, Creamy Garlic Shrimp Cauliflower Rice is a great match. The shrimp brings a little richness, and the cauliflower rice keeps the whole plate from feeling too heavy.

If you’re craving a vegetarian side, Cheesy Garlic Roasted Asparagus adds just enough flavor and a little crispness to balance the softness of the gnocchi. It’s simple, quick, and always works.

And when the mood calls for something more indulgent, Easy Cheesy Garlic Bread never disappoints. There’s something about warm gnocchi next to buttery, golden bread that makes dinner feel extra comforting. If you want something fresher to brighten the plate, the Avocado Corn Tomato Salad balances all the richness perfectly.

FAQs

See It In Action: Step-By-Step

Fork Marks or Smooth?

When it comes to shaping homemade gnocchi, people tend to pick a side: team fork marks or team smooth. I’ve gone back and forth over the years, and honestly, both work beautifully depending on what you’re serving.

Fork-marked gnocchi
These little ridges help catch sauce, especially anything creamy or buttery. If I’m planning to toss the gnocchi in a simple butter sauce or something with parmesan, I’ll take the extra minute to roll each piece against the back of a fork. The texture holds onto every bit of flavor, and it makes the whole dish feel a little more special.

Smooth gnocchi
On busy nights, I skip the ridges and go smooth. They cook evenly, stay tender, and still taste amazing. The smooth ones also crisp up really well if you pan-fry them later, which my kids love when we’re digging into leftovers.