Piña Colada French Toast

This Piña Colada French Toast brings a little vacation magic straight to your breakfast table. Thick slices of bread soak up a creamy coconut mixture, then cook until golden and crisp at the edges. A warm pineapple topping melts over every bite, giving you that perfect mix of sweet fruit and cozy French toast comfort.

It is the kind of pina colada French toast recipe that feels decadent but still easy enough for a slow weekend brunch. If you love playful tropical flavors or simply want a fresh spin on a classic french toast recipe, this one will become a favorite. It tastes like sunshine without ever leaving your kitchen.

What Makes This Recipe So Good

This Piña Colada French Toast takes everything you love about the classic breakfast and gives it a bright, tropical twist. The coconut milk custard makes each slice incredibly soft inside while staying lightly crisp on the outside. The warm pineapple topping adds just the right sweetness and brings that pina colada flavor forward in a way that feels playful but still comforting.

What really sets this version apart is the balance. It is rich without being heavy, sweet without being sugary, and special without being complicated. You get the fun tropical vibe of a pineapple French toast moment, but with the ease and reliability of a simple pina colada French toast recipe you can whip up any morning you want to feel a little extra.

What Goes Into Piña Colada French Toast

Save this recipe!

Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new recipes from us every week!

Email *

Save

This recipe keeps things simple while leaning on a few key ingredients to create that creamy, tropical pina colada flavor. Each one brings something essential, from richness to brightness.

• Coconut Milk: This gives the custard its signature pina colada flavor and helps the bread soak up moisture without becoming soggy. Light coconut milk keeps it creamy while still feeling fresh.
• Crushed Pineapple: The sweet acidity wakes up the entire recipe. It balances the richness from the coconut and adds a natural sweetness that tastes like real fruit rather than added sugar.
• Cream Cheese: Softened low fat cream cheese creates a silky filling that melts slightly as the French toast cooks. It adds body and keeps the coconut and pineapple flavors from tasting too sweet.
• Rum or Rum Extract: Just a small splash lifts every flavor. It gives the French toast that classic pina colada personality without overpowering the fruit or coconut.

Note: Please see recipe card at the bottom for a full list of ingredients with measurements.

How To Make Piña Colada French Toast

1. Make the Custard: Whisk the egg, coconut milk, crushed pineapple, and vanilla in a bowl until the mixture is smooth and fully combined.

2. Cook the French Toast: Soak each slice of bread in the custard, then cook in a nonstick pan over low to medium heat until both sides are golden and lightly crisp.

3. Prepare the Coconut Filling: Mix all the creamy coconut stuffing ingredients in a separate bowl until the mixture becomes soft, smooth, and evenly blended.

4. Assemble and Serve: Spread the filling over one slice of French toast, place the second slice on top, and finish with any remaining filling and extra crushed pineapple.

Since Pina Colada French Toast is sweet and tropical, pairing it with something savory or bright creates a really satisfying balance. Caprese Frittata adds a soft, herby, tomato-and-cheese freshness that lifts the richness of the coconut and pineapple. It brings in protein without stealing the spotlight.

If you want something lighter, Lemon Garlic Asparagus gives a bright, citrusy contrast that keeps the whole meal feeling fresh. For a heartier brunch plate, Sheet Pan Full Breakfast With Garlic Butter Mushrooms adds savory warmth and satisfying texture. Together, these three sides create a deliciously balanced brunch spread.

Tips For Making Piña Colada French Toast

• Day-old bread works best here. It soaks up the custard just right without turning mushy, which makes every bite soft inside and golden outside.
• If you like your French toast extra plush, let the bread linger in the custard a little longer. It feels indulgent in the best way.
• Keep the heat around low to medium. Slow cooking gives you that beautiful even browning instead of a rushed, burnt edge.
• Make sure your cream cheese is really soft before mixing. It makes the filling smooth, spreadable, and honestly a little irresistible.

Recipe FAQ’s