Oysters 3 Ways: A Trio Worth Craving

I love serving oysters when we have people over, because they always start a conversation. Everyone has a favourite style, and watching the table debate which one wins is half the fun. This recipe gives you three options, so there’s something for every person sitting around the table.

Whether you like them bright and fresh, cheesy and baked, or smoky from the grill, this trio covers it. I’ve made these for birthdays, beach days and lazy Sunday gatherings, and they disappear faster than anything else on the menu. They’re simple, but they feel special, which is exactly the kind of food I love to serve.

Three Flavors, One Obsession

• It turns any night into an occasion.
  Oysters have a way of making the table feel a little celebratory, even if it’s just family on a weeknight. The minute the tray comes out, everyone leans in to see which one they’re grabbing first.
• Something for every taste.
  Some people love them fresh, others only eat them baked or grilled. Having three options always makes the table more fun. There’s no pressure to choose one style and it makes even picky eaters curious to try.
• Surprisingly simple to prepare.
  Once you get the hang of opening them, the rest is easy. Each version has just a few ingredients and comes together fast. I’ve made these while friends stand around the kitchen island chatting, and nothing about it feels stressful.
• They never last long.
  Every time I serve oysters this way, the plate is empty before I sit down. Someone always asks for the recipe, which is the best compliment I could ask for.

They’re quick to prep, elegant to serve, and always a conversation starter. For something playful on the side, try my Esquites (Mexican Street Corn Cups).

And if you’re the kind of person who loves a table full of flavors, these oysters fit right in. Keep the coastal vibe going with buttery Garlic Butter Shrimp. Together, it’s a spread that feels like a little celebration of its own.

Shuck It, Let’s Talk Ingredients.

Save this recipe!

Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new recipes from us every week!

Email *

Save

Because the right flavors make all the difference, these are the stars that turn Oysters into three unforgettable bites:

• Fresh oysters.
  Good oysters are everything in this recipe. I always buy them the same day I’m cooking because the flavor is cleaner and they open much easier. If you’re new to shucking, ask your fishmonger to show you once. It makes all the difference and saves a lot of frustration.
• Butter.
  Butter makes the baked and grilled versions rich and satisfying. It melts into the shells and carries the flavor of whatever you put on top. I like using salted butter so I don’t have to fuss with seasoning too much. It also browns beautifully under the broiler.
• Garlic.
  Garlic adds depth without overpowering the oysters. A small amount goes a long way, especially when mixed with butter. I chop it fine instead of using a press so it doesn’t burn or turn bitter in the oven.
• Lemon.
  A squeeze of lemon brightens everything. Even people who don’t usually eat oysters ask for extra lemon wedges. It balances the richness from the butter and highlights the natural flavour of the oysters.

Note: Find the full list of ingredients and measurements in the Recipe Card.

Substitutions

Oysters
If oysters aren’t available where you live, you can use clams or mussels. They’re not the same, but they work beautifully with the same toppings and are easier for beginners. I’ve done this when oysters were sold out and nobody complained.

Butter
You can swap part of the butter for olive oil if you prefer something lighter, but I like keeping at least some butter for the way it browns and crisps under the broiler. It makes a noticeable difference in texture.

Lemon
If you run out of lemons, lime works just fine. It’s a little sharper, but it still brightens the oysters. I’ve used lime plenty of times, especially in summer.

Garlic
If raw garlic feels too strong, roasted garlic mash works really well and adds a more mellow flavor. It blends in smoothly and never burns.

Tips for Success

• Buy oysters the same day you plan to serve them. They taste fresher and open much easier. I made the mistake of buying them ahead once, and they were much harder to work with.
• Keep them on ice until you’re ready to prep. It helps them stay firm and makes shucking safer. I set a tray of ice next to me before I start so everything is ready to go.
• Use a towel or glove when opening. It gives better grip and protects your hand. If you’ve never opened oysters before, you can watch the quick tutorial video here.
• Don’t overbake. Once the topping turns golden, pull them out. A few extra minutes can make them tough, so I like to stay close to the oven while they finish.
• Tools that help. This oyster shucking knife is the one I use at home. It makes the process safer and faster. If you want the oysters to stay level in the oven, a small wire baking rack works great.

How to Make Them

Three ways, eight steps.

Asian:

1. Whisk the Base: Mix sugar, soy, rice vinegar, and mirin until dissolved.

2. Finish the Sauce: Add vegetable oil, sesame oil, and ginger. Spoon over oysters and top with salmon eggs + chives.

Patrick:

3. Crisp the Bacon: Slice into thin strips and fry until golden.

4. Mix the Heat: Combine tomato sauce, Worcestershire, and Tabasco.

5. Top & Grill: Arrange oysters on rock salt, add bacon and 1 tsp sauce each. Grill 2 minutes at 200°C/400°F.

6. Garnish & Serve: Rest 1 minute, sprinkle parsley, and serve over fresh rock salt.

Shallot Vinegar (Mignonette):

7. Make the Mix: Combine minced shallot, red wine vinegar, and pepper. Let’s sit for 2+ hours.

8. Spoon & Serve: Spoon over oysters just before serving.

To build a full platter around your oysters, choose sides that feel just as easy and relaxed. Buttery Garlic Mushrooms add a rich, earthy bite and they take only a few minutes to cook. Garlic Browned Butter Baked Asparagus brings a lighter touch and looks beautiful on the table next to seafood.

If you want to add more seafood to the spread, Crispy Baked Shrimp Scampi is always a fast favourite with its golden garlic parmesan topping. And if you’re feeding a crowd, the Classic Spanish Paella makes a stunning centerpiece that everyone can scoop from together. It turns oysters into a full moment worth sharing.

FAQs

See It In Action: Step-By-Step